How to design comparison pages [with b2b Examples]

There are many brands who uses comparison pages on their websites to help the customer compare them and pick them. Clickup, Customer.io, Notion, Monday, they are all known to do this.

Pitfalls of competitor comparison tactics

An important marketing and brand strategy insight: the pitfalls of competitor comparison tactics. Here’s a breakdown of why these tactics often backfire and how brands can refocus their efforts more effectively:

Why Competitor Comparisons Fail

1. Credibility Perception:
   • Buyers inherently distrust competitor critiques due to the obvious bias. They know the intent is self-serving, which can diminish your credibility rather than enhance it.
2. Unintentional Brand Promotion:
   • Even negative mentions increase the mental availability of competitors. By naming them, you’re reinforcing their relevance in the category, inadvertently validating them as worthy competitors.
3. Psychological Reactance:
   • The boomerang effect in social psychology suggests that aggressive persuasion can trigger resistance, leading buyers to lean toward the competitor instead of away from them.
4. Cognitive Load:
   • Side-by-side comparisons or feature matrices push buyers into a rational, analytical mode, which is cognitively demanding. This increases decision fatigue, slows the buying process, and may lead to inaction.
5. Reinforcement of Weaknesses:
   • Attacking competitors can make your brand appear insecure or overly defensive, which can weaken trust and confidence in your offering.

A Better Approach: Building Your Brand’s Mental Availability

Instead of focusing on competitors, direct your efforts towards:

1. Strengthening Your Unique Value Proposition (UVP):
   • Highlight your differentiators positively, without relying on comparisons.
   • Showcase how your product or service solves pain points, delivers exceptional value, or enhances user experience.
2. Building Emotional Connections:
   • Emotions drive faster, more intuitive decision-making. Use storytelling, relatable messaging, and aspirational brand positioning to create emotional resonance with your audience.
3. Expanding Category Entry Points:
   • Focus on broadening how and where consumers think of your brand. Be present in relevant contexts, channels, and moments that matter to your audience.
4. Leveraging Social Proof:
   • Share success stories, case studies, and testimonials to build trust without needing to discredit competitors.
5. Simplifying Decision Making:
   • Reduce friction in the buying process with clear, straightforward messaging and design that instills confidence and speeds up decision-making.
6. Long-Term Brand Equity:
   • Invest in activities that build trust and familiarity over time, such as consistent branding, quality improvements, and exceptional customer service.

Navigating Leadership Pressure

Leadership often demands aggressive competitive strategies, but it’s important to demonstrate:

• The ineffectiveness of such tactics through data and behavioral insights.
• The value of long-term brand-building efforts over short-term wins.
• Metrics like brand awareness, trust, and loyalty, which are more sustainable indicators of success than discrediting a competitor.

By focusing on your brand’s strengths and leaving competitors out of the spotlight, you ensure buyers see your value without distractions or skepticism.

‍

Customer.io's Comparison Page

‍

‍